Wednesday, May 6, 2015

Finance and Economic Factors at the 1893 Fair

Chicago World's Fair: Birdseye View, Official Print.
From: Artstor. wwww.artstor.org

Initial Predictions

The initial financial predictions for the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition were optimistic, to say the least. In their “Report for the President of the Chicago Company,” The National Committee estimated that total expenditures for the fair would be “liberal beyond expectation,” at about $17,625,435. He estimated the incoming revenue for the fair would be about 18 million, with 5 million coming from the sale of stock, 5 million from the city of Chicago, 7 million from gate receipts, and 1 million from granting concessions.[1]

Entrance Ticket to the World's Fair

In reality, the Chicago Company soon discovered that their predictions were wildly optimistic, and, by the summer of 1891, they realized that they would not have enough money to finance the fair. Part of the reason for inaccurate financial predictions was the confusion over the responsibility for executing the details of the fair. The Chicago Company was in charge of building and design, while the National Commission, a separate board of men, was in charge of the specific exhibition space and internal details. A lack of communication between these two boards resulted in unsound financial decisions. Artists and architects continually made changes in decoration and design without worrying about cost, and these decisions slipped between the oversight of the two separate boards.[2] The continuous demand for more exhibition space and change in number of exhibits slowly increased the cost of the fair as the plans for the exposition grew. The Board of Commissioners allowed contracts to be made before receipt of the funds to pay for the work were received, and much of the construction was done on credit. As a result, by September of 1891, the Fair Officials were scrambling for a way to continue to finance the exposition.[3]

Turning to Congress: Troubles and Loans

On September 2nd of 1891, the head of the Committee on Grounds and Buildings issued a report to the Chicago Company which declared that they needed to either receive more money to fund the construction of the fair or abandon the construction of some of the buildings. In December of 1891, The Chicago Company petitioned congress requesting additional funds for the construction of the fair, declaring that federal support was necessary if America wanted to prove its authority to the world through a grand display a the Fair. In February of 1892, President Harrison declared that he was favorably disposed to federal support. Six months later, in August of 1892, Congress passed a bill that granted 2.5 million dollars to the Fair officials, which, although less than half the amount than what they had asked for, aided the Chicago Company in saving themselves from insolvency. Fair officials also turned to banks, taking out about 45 million in debenture bonds to fund the construction of the fairgrounds.[4]


The Midway and Finance
Another source of financial revenue that fair officials were forced to turn to were vendors who saw the fair as an opportunity to make a fortune in their individual businesses. Originally, fair officials had been opposed to responding to requests from individuals who wanted to sell goods or perform shows; they saw such circus acts and musical troupes as incongruous with the classical ideal and aesthetic of the fair as a whole. Instead, fair commissioners wanted to take an ethnographic approach to entertainment at the fair. They hired G Browne Goode, an advisor from the Smithsonian Institution, and F. W. Putnam, a professor at Harvard to assemble exhibits from around the world that provided an educational representation of various cultures. These exhibitions of social and cultural interest were to take place on the midway, the strip of land that connected Jackson and Washington Park.[5]

Drawing, Unidentified Artist, Dance of the Dahomans in the Midway Plaisance, 1893
From: Artstor: www.artstor.org


Unknown Photographer, Photograph of the Midway, 1893
From: Artstor: www.artstor.org
However, the financial problems that fair commissioners faced soon forced them to rethink this approach. Vendors, circus performers, and other cheap forms of entertainment would provide financial revenue for the fair. These individuals would pay for the use of the Midway, allowing the Chicago company to receive large receipts from these sources that would allow them to pay back the original investors they were indebted to. Further, such forms of entertainment would draw crowds to the fair itself, raising gate receipts and ticket sales. As a result, the Chicago Company decided to hire Sol Bloom, a 22 year old first-generation American who was known for his ability as a salesman. Bloom directly clashed with the ideas of Putnam and Goode; he realized that their ethnographic approach to the Midway would not raise sales for the fair as a whole. He declared that “to have made this unhappy gentleman responsible [Putnam] for the establishment of a successful venture in the field of entertainment was about as intelligent a decision as it would be today to make Albert Einstein manager of the…Bailey Circus!”[6]

Poster Advertising Portraits on the Midway, 1893
From: Artstor: www.artstor.org
With the support of the Chicago Company, Bloom thus turned the Midway largely into a concession and entertainment area. From the erotic “hootchy-cootchy” belly dance in the “Street of Cairo” to the rowdy performances at Buffalo Bill’s “Wild West Show,” the midway became a chaotic, colorful, and energetic site of entertainment that stood in contrast to the stark white walls of the main fairgrounds.Money-making concessions and sideshows made over $4 million dollars, and Bloom became famous as the man who turned the Midway into the most successful amusement area in the history of World Fairs.[7]



[1] Badger, The Great American Fair.
[2] Ibid.
[3] Rothstein, “Field Museum Looks Back at Chicago’s World’s Fair.”
[4] Badger, The Great American Fair.
[5] Larson, The Devil in the White City.
[6] Badger, The Great American Fair.
[7] World’s Columbian Exposition : Chicago, The World’s Fair.

Saturday, April 4, 2015

Primary Sources: Newspaper Articles on Opening Day

Introduction
When the World’s Columbian Exhibition officially opened in Chicago on May 1, 1893, the fair was not quite ready for public visitors. An impossibly harsh winter meant that construction was far behind schedule and several buildings were unfinished. Further, the immense size of the fairgrounds meant that cleaning up the property and surrounding landscape was no easy task. However, visitors knew that Burnham and his team had been hard at work for many months on the fair, and they were sympathetic to their efforts to accomplish a feat as glorious as the White City. Thus, reporters at the time maintained  a careful balance between respectful criticism of the fair’s unfinished state and praise for the momentous grandeur and potential beauty of what was to be.

Front Page of Chicago Daily Tribune on Opening Day

Incomplete Condition of the Fair
Interestingly, most of the articles that came out on opening day of the World’s Columbian Exposition do not discuss the beauty of the White City, nor do they extoll the monumental design of  the fair. This was probably because on May 1, 1893, the majority of the fair was incomplete. Many of the pavilions were not finished with construction, and the fairgrounds were littered with trash and debris.

Map Published Alongside Article in Scientific American
OPENING OF THE WORLD'S COLUMBIAN EXPOSITION, CHICAGO, MAY 1, 1893. (1893, May 06). 
Scientific American (1845-1908), LXVIII., 274.
As reporters wrote about the opening day of the fair, nearly every major newspaper commented on the incomplete state of the fairgrounds. On May 1, 1893, the Chicago Tribute reported that “the public will find the fair still in a somewhat incomplete condition.”[1] Similarly, The New York Times and the Boston Globe mentioned the unfinished nature of the fairgrounds. However, these reporters were generally pretty sensitive to the hard work of Burnham and his team, and were reluctant to blame the fair’s designers for its lack of readiness. The same article in The Tribune continues,  the incomplete nature of the fair is“due more to the tardiness of exhibitors than to any lack of zeal on the part of the management of the exhibition.”[2]

In fact, most newspapers made effort to praise the hard work of the workers and designers despite the unfinished nature of the fair upon opening day. On opening day, the Boston Globe reported: “no praise could be too great for the honest workers who have devoted time, thought, personal nerve and individual industry to the attainment of the desired by hopeless end.”[3]

Similarly, on May 1, 1893, the New York Times made sure to report that despite the unruly appearance of the fair, it was no fault of the fair’s overseers. Their article reads “all the heads of departments were at their desks from morning till night and some of them will not leave the grounds until early in the morning.”[4]

Weather
It seemed that rather than condone the efforts of the fair workers, newspapers were more apt to place the blame of the fair’s unfinished appearance on the terrible weather conditions leading up to opening day. On their report of the opening day of the Exposition, nearly every major newspaper mentioned the difficulty that the weather had posed in the construction and completion of the fairgrounds.

Headline from Boston's Daily Globe on May 1, 1893

The Boston Globe’ s headline read: “World’s Fair Will Open in the Storm or Sunshine.”[5] While the New York Times proclaimed: “The Opening Services To-Day Rain or Shine.”[6] The weather was described in extreme and graphic detail. “It was raining in torrents and blowing a gale from the northeast…this   morning,” one reporter wrote.[7] Another described the “varying degrees of must, deluge, bluster and zephyristic wave.”[8]

These intense descriptions of the terrible weather seemed to serve as excuses for the unfinished condition of the fair itself.    “Providence was against them,” and it was only by their own sheer will power and skill that the fair workers were able to get the fairgrounds ready for opening day.[9]

Even General Davis, one of the chiefs of the fair, is quoted blaming conditions out of his control for the problems surrounding opening day. In an article from the New York Times he says, “we have been delayed by the unprecedentedly bad weather, by labor troubles, by tardy exhibitors, and by a thousand and one things that were unforeseen and could not be guarded against, but after all we have pulled through satisfactorily.” If only it does not rain to-morrow, we shall all be perfectly happy.”[10]

In pitching opening day as a struggle between the fair workers and the rough elements of nature, which God was deliberately thrusting upon the fair in order to prohibit the fair’s opening, these reporters created a melodramatic news story out of what was in reality, poor planning on the part of the fair architects and a few bad days of rain.          

Illustration from the Los Angeles Times

The reporters may have been reluctant to blame the fair’s organizers for the unfinished nature of the fair in order to maintain a sense of national pride in the Exposition. Reports of opening day would be read all around the world, and every major city, from New York to Boston, wanted to portray America as capable of organizing and staging a fair as great as the nations that had done so before.

Most articles end with a distant hope that conditions will improve in the future, fixating again on the excuses for delays rather than on the fair itself. The New York Times concludes its article by turning again to trivial issues of weather and also hope for better conditions in the future “the local weather officer predicts fair weather for this vincinity tomorrow and every one hopes he is right in his guess.”[11]





[1] “ALL WILL BE READY.”
[2] Ibid.
[3] “CHICAGO’S DAY OF DAYS.”
[4] “READY FOR THE GREAT FAIR.”
[5] “CHICAGO’S DAY OF DAYS.”
[6] Rothstein, “Field Museum Looks Back at Chicago’s World’s Fair.”
[7] “READY FOR THE GREAT FAIR.”
[8] “CHICAGO’S DAY OF DAYS.”
[9] Ibid.
[10] “READY FOR THE GREAT FAIR.”
[11] Ibid.